5354 North High Street, Columbus, OH 43214 · Free consultations Call (614) 547-5757
The Law Office ofJames D. Owen, LLC
Empty wood-paneled courtroom with the judge's bench, jury box and gallery benches
Courtroom Victories

A Trial Record Second to None

Not-guilty verdicts and dismissals from Columbus, central Ohio and federal court, including three death-penalty murder acquittals.

26not-guilty verdicts listed
14cases or charges dismissed
3death-penalty acquittals
  • State of Ohiov.Richard K.

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    Indictment for two counts of Rape and one count of Gross Sexual Imposition. Jury issued a verdict of NOT GUILTY for all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Calvin Fluellen, aka EKT 40

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    Indictment for Participating in a Criminal Gang and Aggravated Robbery. Jury issued a verdict of NOT GUILTY entered on both charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Eric Bickham

    Not guilty
    Verdict

    Indictment for Aggravated Burglary, Domestic Violence, and Abduction. Verdict of NOT GUILTY entered on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Yusuf Sankoh

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    Indictment for Abduction and Felonious Assault. Jury rendered a verdict of NOT GUILTY of all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Tyler Bourdo

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    Indictment for Aggravated Burglary, Felonious Assault, and Assault. Jury rendered a verdict of NOT GUILTY of all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Patrick Osadebe

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    Indictment for Rape and Gross Sexual Imposition. Jury rendered a verdict of NOT GUILTY of all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Mark Bennett

    Dismissed
    Dismissed after two hung juries

    Indictment for intimidation of a witness by threatening in a tape-recorded conversation to put a contract on the life of a law enforcement officer. After two jury trials ended in a hung jury, the indictment was DISMISSED at the request of the prosecution.

  • State of Ohiov.Quander Farmer

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    Our client, a young man who lived in Newark, Ohio with an extensive prior criminal record related to possession and sale of marijuana, was charged with two crimes. The first was Aggravated Trafficking of Drugs involving a large amount of Oxycodone, a First Degree Felony. The second involved Aggravated Possession of Drugs, a Second Degree Felony. After a hotly contested jury trial, the jury found our client NOT GUILTY of both charges.

  • State of Ohiov.John S.

    Not guilty
    Bench trial

    Our client, a middle-aged Columbus man with a prior criminal record, was charged with Ethnic Intimidation, Assault, and Criminal Damaging that allegedly occurred after a road rage incident. After waiving a jury and trying the case before a Franklin County Judge, the Court found our client NOT GUILTY of all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Fredericka Wagner

    Dismissed
    Dismissed

    Our client, a 77 year old Pike County woman, known as the Matriarch of the Wagner family, was charged with Perjury and Obstructing Justice as part of a cover-up of the investigation into the mass murder of eight members of the Rhoden Family. After a seven-month war with opposing lawyers from the Ohio Attorney General’s office and the Pike County Prosecutor’s office, it became clear that our client was NOT GUILTY of both charges. Accordingly, on June 26, 2019, the Court ordered the CASE DISMISSED.

  • State of Ohiov.Penick

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    Our client, a middle-aged Columbus man with no prior criminal record, was charged with Felonious Assault. After a 4-day jury trial, the jury deliberated less than 30 minutes before finding him NOT GUILTY.

  • State of Ohiov.Bradley

    Dismissed
    Dismissed

    Our client was charged with Discharging a Firearm into a Habitation, a second degree felony, and Discharging a Firearm in a Prohibited Premises, a third degree felony. On the date to hear motions to suppress, the Court ordered the CASE DISMISSED.

  • State of Ohiov.Bowie

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    Former NFL Football Player (Oakland Raiders and Cleveland Browns) from Columbus was charged with Carrying a Concealed Weapon and Improper Handling of Firearms in a Motor Vehicle. The jury found him NOT GUILTY of all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Brown

    Dismissed
    Dismissed

    Our client, a 24-year-old Columbus man, was charged with Burglary, after his DNA was found inside a burglarized apartment. After extensive pretrial preparation, and during jury selection, the Court ordered the CASE DISMISSED.

  • State of Ohiov.Mirreh

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    Our client, a young Columbus man, was charged with Kidnapping and Attempted Rape. The jury found the client NOT GUILTY on both charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Krug

    Dismissed
    Dismissed

    The client, a young Columbus woman, was charged with Forgery. After filing a Motion to Dismiss based on constitutional speedy trial grounds, the Court ordered the CASE DISMISSED.

  • State of Ohiov.Turner

    Not guilty
    Murder · Jury verdict

    Our client, a young central Ohio man, was charged with Murder and three counts of Involuntary Manslaughter. The jury found the client NOT GUILTY on all four charges. He was immediately released from jail.

  • State of Ohiov.Howard

    Dismissed
    Murder · Post-conviction · Dismissed

    Twenty years after Timothy Howard’s Columbus conviction for Aggravated Murder and Aggravated Robbery, attorneys from our Columbus law firm began representing him. After years of hard work our attorneys uncovered powerful new evidence of innocence. After a lengthy post-conviction hearing, we were able to obtain Mr. Howard’s release, a new trial, and the subsequent dismissal of all charges. Later, we helped obtain a $2.5 Million Dollar settlement for Mr. Howard’s wrongful incarceration. CASE DISMISSED.

  • State of Ohiov.Harris

    Dismissed
    Dismissed

    Our client, a young Columbus man, was charged with Aggravated Robbery with a firearm specification. After extensive pretrial litigation, the Court ordered the CASE DISMISSED.

  • State of Ohiov.James

    Dismissed
    Murder · Post-conviction · Dismissed

    Our client, Gary James, was indicted for Aggravated Murder with a death penalty specification and Aggravated Robbery. In 1977, Gary was convicted and sentenced to death. In 1997, Gary wrote to Mr. Owen and asked for his help in proving his innocence. Mr. Owen teamed up with Centurion Ministries and began representing Mr. James some 20 years after his conviction. Working with Centurion Ministries, Mr. Owen helped obtain Gary’s release, a new trial, and the subsequent dismissal of all charges. Later, Mr. Owen obtained a $1.5 Million Dollar settlement for his client’s wrongful incarceration. Upon his release from prison, Gary obtained employment at the Office of the Ohio Secretary of State and married a retired Columbus middle school teacher. Gary has now retired and resides quietly in a Columbus suburb. CASE DISMISSED.

  • State of Ohiov.Resh

    Relief granted
    Murder · Post-conviction · New trial

    Resh was indicted for Aggravated Murder with death specifications and Attempted Rape. Convicted of Murder and Attempted Rape. Nearly 12 years after being indicted, and with our help, he was granted a new trial.

  • State of Ohiov.Montgomery

    Dismissed
    Murder charge dismissed

    Our client, a 26-year-old Columbus man was charged with Murder and guns. After gathering evidence of self-defense, the Court ordered the Murder charge DISMISSED. He was however convicted of a minor gun charge.

  • State of Ohiov.Hairston

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict · Capital case

    Indictment for Aggravated Murder with death specifications among other charges. After a 3-week jury trial, the Columbus jury announced a verdict of NOT GUILTY on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Reeves

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    The client, a middle aged Columbus man, was charged with Rape and Gross Sexual Imposition allegedly involving his girlfriend’s minor daughter. After a week-long jury trial, the jury found the client NOT GUILTY on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Lopez

    Dismissed
    Dismissed

    Our client, a young Columbus man, was charged with Burglary. After our lawyers attacked the credibility of eyewitnesses who identified our client, the Court ordered the CASE DISMISSED.

  • State of Ohiov.Green

    Not guilty
    Directed verdict

    The client, a young Columbus man, was charged with Possession of Criminal Tools. After the prosecution rested its case, the Court directed a verdict of NOT GUILTY on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Jones

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict · Entrapment

    Aggravated Drug Trafficking for multiple sales of narcotics to an undercover police officer. After a week-long trial, the Columbus jury found the client NOT GUILTY on all charges, finding that the narcotics officer entrapped the client.

  • State of Ohiov.Walker

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    The client, a young Columbus man, was charged with Aggravated Vehicular Homicide. The jury announced a NOT GUILTY verdict on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Cross

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    The client, an early 20s Columbus woman with no prior record, was charged with Aggravated Drug Trafficking in connection with the possession of 11 ounces of cocaine. After a week-long trial, the jury found the client NOT GUILTY on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Hollman I

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict · Capital case

    Aggravated Murder with death penalty specifications and other charges. The Columbus jury announced a NOT GUILTY verdict on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Hollman II

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    Multiple counts of Aggravated Robbery, Aggravated Burglary, Kidnapping, and Felonious Assault with a firearm. The Columbus jury issued a NOT GUILTY verdict on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Hollman III

    Dismissed
    Dismissed

    The client was charged with Aggravated Burglary, Kidnapping, and Rape, all in connection with an alleged incident involving a former girlfriend. After an extensive pretrial investigation, the Court ordered the CASE DISMISSED.

  • State of Ohiov.Brown

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    The client, a young Columbus man, was charged with Kidnapping, Aggravated Robbery, Aggravated Burglary, and 3 counts of Rape. After a week-long trial, the jury found the client NOT GUILTY on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Berry

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict · Capital case

    Aggravated Murder with death penalty specifications and other charges. The Columbus jury announced a NOT GUILTY verdict on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Gurden

    Not guilty
    Federal jury verdict

    Our client was charged with Federal firearms violations. After a lengthy trial in federal court, the Columbus jury found the client NOT GUILTY on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Smith

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    The client, a Columbus teenager, was charged with the Robbery of a local convenience store. The jury found the client NOT GUILTY of all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Mefford

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    The client, a retired Worthington man, was charged with multiple counts of Gross Sexual Imposition and one count of Attempted Rape. After a week-long trial, the Columbus jury found the client NOT GUILTY on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Ridenbaugh

    Dismissed
    Dismissed

    Indictment for 3 Counts of Rape and 4 Counts of Sexual Battery. ALL CHARGES DISMISSED.

  • State of Ohiov.Marsh

    Dismissed
    Dismissed

    Indictment for Unlawful Sexual Conduct with a Minor. ALL CHARGES DISMISSED.

  • State of Ohiov.Maverick Foster

    Dismissed
    Reversed on appeal · Dismissed

    Indictment for felonious assault with a firearm among other charges. A jury trial concluded with a conviction on all charges. The conviction was reversed on direct appeal based on multiple errors raised in the trial court. The indictment was dismissed upon request of the prosecutor after reversal by the court of appeals.

  • Timothy Howardv.State of Ohio

    Not guilty
    Civil murder trial · Jury verdict

    Civil murder trial. After a week-long jury trial, a jury of eight issued a verdict of NOT GUILTY on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Robert Sheppard

    Mistrial
    Hung jury

    Indictment for carrying a concealed weapon. A jury trial concluded with a mistrial due to a deadlocked jury.

  • State of Ohiov.Nancy Flaherty

    Relief granted
    Capital case · Reversed on appeal

    Indictment for aggravated murder with death penalty specifications among other charges. A jury trial concluded with a conviction on all charges. The conviction was reversed on direct appeal based on errors raised in the trial court. After reversal, the case was resolved by a plea to a lesser offense with a promise of probation.

Because each case is different, no expectations should be made about the results that can be achieved in your case or in any other case. Past performance is not an accurate predictor of future results.

Charged with a crime in Columbus? Talk to us before you talk to anyone else.

Free, confidential consultation · (614) 547-5757