Involuntary Manslaughter is one of the more misunderstood homicide charges in Ohio, largely because it does not require the state to prove any intent to cause a death at all. Understanding exactly what prosecutors must show — and what they don’t have to show — is critical to building a defense.
How Ohio Law Defines Involuntary Manslaughter
Involuntary Manslaughter is defined in ORC 2903.04 and comes in two forms. The first, under ORC 2903.04(A), applies when a death occurs as the proximate result of the offender committing or attempting to commit a felony. The second, under ORC 2903.04(B), is identical except that it involves an underlying misdemeanor of any degree rather than a felony.
Do Prosecutors Have to Prove You Intended to Kill Someone?
No. This is what sets Involuntary Manslaughter apart from every other homicide charge in Ohio. No mental state — purpose, knowledge, recklessness, or negligence — needs to be proven with respect to the death itself. The accused doesn’t need to have intended a death, foreseen a death, recklessly caused a death, or even negligently caused a death. The only mental state required is whatever is needed to commit or attempt the underlying felony or misdemeanor.
The Causation Requirement
Even though no intent is required as to the death, causation still matters. For Involuntary Manslaughter to apply, the death must be directly connected to the underlying crime as part of one continuous chain of events — not a separate, unrelated occurrence that merely happened at some point after the underlying offense.
Involuntary Manslaughter vs. Murder, Reckless Homicide, and Negligent Homicide
Murder generally requires either intent to kill or a death during one of a small list of specific serious violent felonies. Involuntary Manslaughter casts a much wider net, since it can be based on any underlying felony or misdemeanor, with no intent to kill required at all. It also differs from Reckless Homicide and Negligent Homicide, both of which require the state to prove a specific mental state as to the death itself.
Learn what “reckless” means under Ohio law.
Why This Charge Often Appears Alongside Other Homicide Counts
Involuntary Manslaughter is frequently charged as one of several counts in the same indictment as Murder or Serious Felony Murder, rather than standing alone. Prosecutors do this because it gives a jury an alternate path to conviction if they aren’t convinced the state proved the more serious charge. This also means Involuntary Manslaughter can become the charge a jury settles on when a self-defense or accident argument persuades them the killing wasn’t purposeful, but the underlying felony or misdemeanor still occurred. Because of this, a strong defense strategy has to account for every count in the indictment, not just the top charge.
What Counts as the “Underlying” Felony or Misdemeanor?
Almost any felony or misdemeanor can serve as the underlying offense for an Involuntary Manslaughter charge — common examples include drug offenses, domestic violence, assault, and even lower-level offenses like disorderly conduct when a death unexpectedly results. Because the underlying offense does the heavy lifting in this charge, disputing whether that offense actually occurred, or whether the state can prove the accused committed it, is often the most direct way to attack the case.
Penalties for Involuntary Manslaughter in Ohio
Involuntary Manslaughter resulting from an underlying felony is a first-degree felony, punishable by a definite prison term of 3 to 11 years. Involuntary Manslaughter resulting from an underlying misdemeanor is a third-degree felony, punishable by 9 to 36 months. If the offender was under the influence of alcohol or a drug of abuse at the time of the offense, Ohio law requires the court to impose a mandatory prison term.
Consequences Beyond the Prison Sentence
A conviction for involuntary manslaughter follows a person long after the sentence ends.
- Loss of gun rights: involuntary manslaughter is an “offense of violence” under ORC 2901.01(A)(9). Under ORC 2923.13(A)(2), anyone convicted of a felony offense of violence may not acquire, have, carry or use a firearm unless relieved from that disability by operation of law or legal process.
- Jobs and licenses: Ohio’s background-check rules list involuntary manslaughter as a disqualifying offense for many positions, including school bus and van drivers and paid direct-care workers.
- A wrongful death lawsuit: the person’s family can file a civil wrongful death claim under ORC Chapter 2125, brought for the benefit of the surviving spouse, children and parents, and the court can award damages including funeral and burial expenses. The Ohio Constitution (Article I, Section 19a) provides that wrongful death damages cannot be limited by law.
How We Defend Involuntary Manslaughter Charges
Because this charge hinges entirely on the underlying felony or misdemeanor and the causal chain leading to death, an effective defense often focuses on disputing whether the underlying offense actually occurred, whether the accused actually committed it, or whether the death was truly part of one continuous chain of events connected to that offense.
See all 12 ways we defend murder and homicide cases in Ohio.
Case Results
Jeremy Turner was charged with Serious Felony Murder, two counts of Involuntary Manslaughter, Tampering with Evidence, and Possessing a Weapon Under Disability, all with firearm specifications. Turner claimed self-defense, and the jury found him not guilty of every count except the weapons charge — he was released from jail the same day, having already served his time on that offense.
See some of our homicide case victories.
Because each case is different, no expectations should be made about the results that can be achieved in your case or in any other case. Past performance is not an accurate predictor of future results.