5354 North High Street, Columbus, OH 43214 · Free consultations Call (614) 547-5757
The Law Office ofJames D. Owen, LLC
Blog

What do police officers look for when attempting to detect drunk driving?

DUI

Signs Of Drunk Driving

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), part of the Department of Transportation, has produced a guide developed during 3 field studies involving hundreds of police officers and more than 12,000 traffic stops, which is entitled “The Visual Detection of DWI Motorists.” This was developed for use by police officers to detect drunk drivers, and most patrol officers have been trained by NHTSA regarding this guide. The guide lists 24 driving behaviors regarded as “cues” for police officers to look for when determining whether make a traffic stop to investigate possible drunk driving. The driving cues are divided into 4 categories: 1) Problems in maintaining proper lane position; 2) Speed and braking problems; 3) Vigilance problems; and 4) Judgment problems. The NHTSA guide claims that the cues presented in these categories predict that a driver in under the influence at least 35% of the time. It also claims that if an officer observes any of the weaving cues and any of the other listed cues, then the probability of driving under the influence jumps to at least 60%. The 24 cues are listed below:

Problems Maintaining Proper Lane Position

    • Almost striking a vehicle or other object
    • Turning with a wide radius
    • Drifting
    • Weaving
    • Weaving across lane lines
    • Straddlng a lane line
    • Swerving

Speed and Braking Problems

    • Slow speed (10+ mph under the limit)
    • Varying Speed
    • Accelerating or decelerating for no apparent reason
    • Stopping problems (too far, too short, or too jerky)

Vigilance Problems

    • Failure to signal or signal inconsistent with action
    • Driving without headlights at night
    • Stopping in lane for no apparent reason
    • Slow or failure to respond to police officer’s signals
    • Driving in opposing lanes or wrong way on one-way street
    • Slow response to traffic signals

Judgment Problems

    • Following too closely
    • Improper or unsafe lane change
    • Illegal or improper turn (too fast, jerky, or sharp)
    • Driving on other than the designated roadway
    • Stopping inappropriately in response to officer
    • Inappropriate or unusual behavior (such as throwing items out of the car)
    • Appearing to be impaired (by gripping the wheel too tight, or driving too close to the windshield)

What Officers Observe After Pulling You Over

Once an officer has initiated a stop, they begin making additional observations before you are even asked to step out of the vehicle. There are three things officers are specifically trained to look for from the moment they approach your window — often called the “Big 3”:

  1. Odor of alcohol — Officers note whether they detect any smell of alcohol coming from the vehicle or directly from you.
  2. Bloodshot or watery eyes — Redness or glassiness is treated as an indicator of impairment, though many conditions completely unrelated to alcohol can produce this.
  3. Slurred speech — Officers listen closely to how you respond to questions for signs of impaired speech.

Beyond the Big 3, officers are also trained to note whether you fumble for your license and registration, how you respond to their questions, whether open containers are visible in the vehicle, your general coordination as you exit, and anything unusual about your demeanor or behavior.

How Field Sobriety Test Results Drive the Arrest Decision

After making initial observations, the single most important factor in whether an officer makes a DUI arrest is how you perform on Standardized Field Sobriety Tests (SFSTs). Ohio officers administer these tests strictly and score drivers on very specific, technical “clues” — clues that often have little to do with whether the person was actually impaired to drive.

Ohio courts apply a “substantial compliance” standard to SFST administration — officers don’t have to administer the tests perfectly, but they must follow procedures closely enough. Whether the officer met that standard in your case is a defense argument worth examining.

Non-Legal Factors That Also Influence the Arrest

What doesn’t appear in police reports is that several non-legal factors influence an officer’s arrest decision as well: the officer’s own age, experience level, and personal attitudes toward alcohol; whether the officer specializes in DUI enforcement; how cooperative and respectful the driver was during the stop; and the driver’s race and gender. An experienced DUI defense attorney understands these dynamics and knows how to challenge the basis for an arrest at trial.

Keep reading

Related articles

Charged with a crime in Columbus? Talk to us before you talk to anyone else.

Free, confidential consultation · (614) 547-5757