5354 North High Street, Columbus, OH 43214 · Free consultations Call (614) 547-5757
The Law Office ofJames D. Owen, LLC
Blog

Do You Have The Right To Self-Defense in Ohio? Part I: Deadly Force

Self-Defense

In Ohio, a person has a legal right to use force to defend himself, another person, his house, or even his property. The level of force that may be lawfully used varies, of course, depending on the circumstances of the case. A claim of self-defense is typically raised by a person accused of murder, attempted murder, felonious assault, aggravated assault, or assault.

As a criminal defense lawyer, I have been truly surprised by the number of people I meet who do not believe that a person in Ohio has the right to self-defense. In fact, the defense of self-defense is firmly established in Ohio law. Of course, the use of deadly force to defend oneself requires greater justification than does the use of non-deadly force. In this blog post, I will discuss a person’s right to use deadly force when acting in self-defense.

The right to use deadly force in self-defense in Ohio can be traced back more than a century. In Marts v. State, 26 Ohio St. 162 (1875), for example, the Ohio Supreme Court held that the use of deadly force is justifiable when a person has an honest belief, and reasonable grounds to believe, even if mistaken, that he is in imminent danger of death or great bodily harm, and that his only means of escape will be by taking the life of his assailant. More than a century later, in State v. Melchior, 56 Ohio St. 2d 15 (1978), the Ohio Supreme Court established the elements of self-defense in a case where the accused actually used deadly force.

There, the Ohio Supreme Court held that the accused who used deadly force must show:

(1) that he was not at fault in creating the situation giving rise to the affray;

(2) that he had a bona fide belief that he was in imminent danger of death or great bodily harm, and that his only means of escape from such danger was the use of such force; and

(3) he did not violate any duty to retreat to avoid the danger.

With respect to the duty to retreat, there is no duty to retreat from one’s own home before resorting to lethal force in self-defense, even against a cohabitant with an equal right to be in the home. See State v. Thomas, 77 Ohio St. 3d 323 (1997).

Using Non-Deadly Force in Self-Defense

The right to defend yourself doesn’t only apply when your life is at risk. Under Ohio law, a person may use reasonable non-deadly force to protect themselves even when faced with a danger that falls short of death or great bodily harm. See State v. Fox, 36 Ohio App. 3d 24 (1986).

The key is proportionality. The force used must be reasonable given what the defender believed was necessary to protect themselves from imminent danger. It is not justifiable to use a greater degree of force than appears necessary. The danger doesn’t have to be real — it only has to be reasonably perceived.

One important distinction from the deadly force standard: there is no duty to retreat when using non-deadly force. The duty to retreat applies only when deadly force is used.

The same “not-at-fault” requirement applies here — only a person who did not start or provoke the confrontation may claim the right to use force in self-defense. If you find yourself charged with assault, aggravated assault, or felonious assault after defending yourself, a jury will ultimately decide whether the force you used was reasonable under the circumstances.

The First Aggressor Rule

A person who starts a fight cannot then claim self-defense during that same fight. This is the “not-at-fault” rule established in State v. Melchior, 56 Ohio St. 2d 12 (1978). To successfully claim self-defense in Ohio, you must not have been the first aggressor in the incident.

In many self-defense cases, the central factual question — who started it — is exactly what the jury has to decide. This is where evidence strategy matters.

Under Rule 404(A)(2) of the Ohio Rules of Evidence, a defendant claiming self-defense may introduce evidence of the alleged victim’s character for violence to support the argument that the alleged victim was in fact the first aggressor. Furthermore, if you knew that the alleged victim had a reputation for violent behavior, or knew of specific prior violent acts by that person, that prior history can be introduced as evidence that you reasonably believed you were in danger when you acted. See State v. Marsh, 71 Ohio App. 3d 64 (1990).

An experienced criminal defense attorney must understand how to use Ohio’s evidentiary rules to get this kind of evidence before a jury — including navigating hearsay exceptions — to build the strongest possible case that you acted in reasonable self-defense.

The Right to Defend Others in Ohio

Ohio’s self-defense law extends beyond protecting yourself. If you believe that another person — a family member, a friend, or even a complete stranger — is in imminent danger of bodily harm, you may use reasonably necessary force to defend that person, to the same extent that the person being threatened would be entitled to act in their own self-defense. See State v. Williford, 49 Ohio St. 3d 247 (1990).

Some states limit the defense of others to a person’s immediate family. Ohio does not. The right applies whenever you render assistance to a third person, regardless of your relationship to them.

There is one important limitation: your right to defend a third person is bounded by that person’s own right to use force. If the person you are defending would not have had the legal right to defend themselves in that situation — for example, because they were the first aggressor — then you cannot claim defense of others on their behalf.

In Ohio, the right of self-defense is an affirmative defense, meaning that the burden of proof rests on the accused to prove that he acted in self-defense when he inflicted the deadly force. However, effective with the passage of SB 184, in 2008, under what is known as the “Castle Doctrine,” if the lethal force was inflicted against a person in your home, temporary place of residence, or occupied car, you are now entitled to a presumption that you acted in self-defense. In this situation, the burden has now shifted to the prosecution to prove that you did not act in self-defense.

If you are currently under investigation for, or charged with, murder, attempted murder, felonious assault, aggravated assault, or assault, and acted in self-defense, you should promptly consult with an experienced Columbus criminal attorney to discuss your legal right to act in self-defense in Ohio.

Keep reading

Related articles

Charged with a crime in Columbus? Talk to us before you talk to anyone else.

Free, confidential consultation · (614) 547-5757