
Case results speak louder than marketing claims. Below is a record of James D. Owen’s most significant homicide case outcomes, grouped by the type of win — from death penalty acquittals to wrongful conviction exonerations.
Death Penalty Acquittals, Exonerations and Not-Guilty Verdicts
James D. Owen has won three consecutive death penalty murder acquittals in Ohio, helped exonerate multiple wrongfully convicted clients through the Ohio Innocence Project and Centurion, Inc., and has spent more than four decades trying homicide cases in Columbus courtrooms. That record is detailed below, organized by the type of result achieved.
Death Penalty Acquittals (Capital Murder Wins)
Donald Hairston (1986)
James D. Owen began building his legal reputation 40 years ago when he helped secure the acquittal of Donald Hairston, accused of killing well-known Columbus businessman and prominent local politician John Meysenburg. Owen personally interviewed dozens of people living near the crime scene and followed up on what they told him, uncovering critical evidence overlooked by police months earlier. Despite a highly publicized escape attempt by Hairston, who was nearly shot by a deputy sheriff during the attempt, Owen won Ohio’s first death penalty murder acquittal after the state reinstated the death penalty in 1981.
Anthony Bernard Hollman
Two years after the Hairston verdict, Owen won a second death penalty murder acquittal in the case of Anthony Bernard Hollman, who remains a free man to this day.
William Berry II
Shortly after the Hollman victory, Owen won a third consecutive death penalty murder acquittal in the case of William Berry II. The defense destroyed the credibility of the state’s primary eyewitness through testimony from three people who knew the witness well and described his reputation as that of a pathological liar. The jury unanimously found William Berry not guilty of all charges.
Self-Defense and Not-Guilty Verdicts
Jeremy Turner
Jeremy Turner was charged with one count of Serious Felony Murder, two counts of Involuntary Manslaughter (all with firearm specifications), one count of Tampering with Evidence, and one count of Possessing a Weapon While Under Disability. Turner claimed self-defense and was found not guilty of every count except the weapons charge, for which he had already served his time — he was released from jail the same day as the verdict.
C.M. — Columbus Bar Shooting
A client identified as C.M. was indicted for Murder after a fight at a Columbus bar escalated when another patron displayed a weapon and a struggle ensued, ending with C.M. shooting and killing the other man. After investigating witnesses from the bar that night, including video captured by patrons and the bar’s owner, it became clear the shooting was self-defense. The homicide charges were dismissed entirely, though C.M. was convicted of a related weapons charge.
Reduced Charges: Lesser-Offense Wins
Jacob M.
A client identified as Jacob M. was charged with Aggravated Murder and Murder in connection with the close-range shooting death of his wife. He admitted to police that he shot her, but the defense argued the shooting was accidental or, at worst, negligent or reckless. The jury acquitted him of both Murder and Aggravated Murder, convicting him only of the lesser offense of Reckless Homicide.
Wrongful Conviction Exonerations
Timothy Howard & Gary James
Timothy Howard and Gary James were wrongfully convicted and sentenced to death in 1977 for a robbery and murder at an East-side Columbus bank. James D. Owen became involved in the case 20 years after their convictions, working alongside Centurion, Inc. After a painstaking reinvestigation uncovered evidence of innocence, the court granted both men new trials 26 years after their original conviction. Prosecutors ultimately dismissed all charges against both men and agreed to expunge their convictions. Owen later helped both men secure what were then the largest wrongful-imprisonment awards in Ohio history.
Randy Resh & Robert Gondor
James D. Owen also helped secure the exoneration of Randy Resh and Robert Gondor, two more men wrongfully convicted of homicides they did not commit, using the same painstaking approach of identifying flaws in the original police investigation.
Science and Expert Witness Wins
Portage County Case
In a Portage County, Ohio case, prosecutors believed the bedliner of a client’s truck contained a murder victim’s blood in the exact location a confidential informant claimed the client had transported a body. Independent testing by a retained expert demonstrated the substance was actually human sweat, and that the DNA recovered was too degraded to connect to any specific person.
Affiliations That Reflect a Commitment to Getting It Right
James D. Owen has volunteered his time working alongside two nationally recognized innocence organizations. The Ohio Innocence Project, based at the University of Cincinnati College of Law, has won the release of 28 wrongfully convicted Ohioans. Centurion, Inc., a Princeton-based innocence organization, has freed 70 innocent people nationwide.
| Attorney Advertising Disclosure: Case results depend upon a variety of factors unique to each case. Case results do not guarantee or predict a similar result in any future case. Every case is different, and prior outcomes are not a promise of any particular result. |