5354 North High Street, Columbus, OH 43214 · Free consultations Call (614) 547-5757
The Law Office ofJames D. Owen, LLC
Ohio Super Lawyers magazine spread of “The Wrong Men,” an article about James D. Owen’s wrongful-conviction work
Press Coverage

In the News

Over the years, Mr. Owen has been featured in many state and national magazines and newspapers. These are the stories, summarized, with links to the full articles.

Front page17 articles
Profile

A Lawyer Who Wins

Jon Craig, former Statehouse reporter for the Cincinnati Enquirer

James D. Owen in the courtroom.
James D. Owen in the courtroom.

Former Statehouse reporter Jon Craig set out to document Jim's trial record. He reviewed the backgrounds of dozens of Central Ohio defense lawyers and sent questionnaires to 11 of them about their not-guilty verdicts. His article traces Jim's reputation to three Franklin County death-penalty acquittals: Donald Hairston in 1986, Anthony Bernard Hollman two years later, and William Berry II in 1992.

It also retells courtroom moments jurors did not forget. A firearms expert's "accidental" discharge of a blank-loaded shotgun helped spare a client's life. A masked reenactment during a 2009 Springfield self-defense trial preceded an acquittal. The article closes with Jim's six-year fight to free Timothy Howard and Gary James.

Owen has an uncanny ability to get into a jury's head.

Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Tim Horton
Wrongful convictions

Freeing Timothy Howard and Gary James

Sentenced to death in 1977 for a bank robbery and murder they always denied, the two men spent 26 years in prison before their convictions were thrown out.

In 1997 Jim joined James McCloskey of Centurion Ministries to reinvestigate the 1976 robbery of an Ohio National Bank branch on East Main Street, where 74-year-old guard Berne Davis was killed. Over six years they uncovered evidence the original defense never saw, including an FBI witness statement and crime-scene fingerprints that matched neither man.

Judge Michael H. Watson overturned Howard's conviction in April 2003. James was freed that July, when prosecutors agreed to dismiss all charges against both men. A jury later found Howard actually innocent, and he received a $2.5 million settlement, at the time the largest of its kind in Ohio history. James was declared wrongfully convicted in 2007.

Holy Cow, we may have the wrong guys on the other job.

Retired FBI agent Philip R. Kerby, testifying in court

There's not one single piece of evidence that ties Timmy to this crime.

James D. Owen
Jim Owen with Tim Howard after helping free him from 26 years in prison.
Jim Owen with Tim Howard after helping free him from 26 years in prison.

The coverage 10 articles

  1. The Columbus Dispatch

    Were They Wrongly Convicted?

    By Alan Johnson · Sunday front page

    The new evidence Jim and Centurion Ministries put before Judge Watson, including sworn statements from Howard's original defense attorney and James's sentencing judge.

  2. The Columbus Dispatch

    Judge Sets New Hearing in 25-Year-Old Murder Case

    By Alan Johnson

    Judge Watson schedules a hearing on new and previously withheld evidence.

  3. The Columbus Dispatch

    Convicts May Be "Wrong Guys"

    By Alan Johnson

    Under Jim's questioning, a retired FBI agent testifies that he long doubted the two men were the robbers.

  4. The Columbus Dispatch

    26 Years in Hell

    By Alan Johnson · Front page

    Judge Watson overturns Howard's conviction, and the two men face a world that moved on without them.

  5. The Columbus Dispatch

    Finally, Freedom

    By Alan Johnson · Front page

    Howard walks out of the Franklin County jail as a free man after 26 years.

  6. The Columbus Dispatch

    Wrongfully Convicted, Now Free as a Bird

    By Alan Johnson · Front page

    Gary James is released as the prosecutor agrees to dismiss all charges against both men.

  7. The Columbus Dispatch

    Freed Man Not at Bank During Killing, Jury Told

    Howard testifies at the civil trial held to prove he is actually innocent.

  8. The Columbus Dispatch

    $2.5 Million Approved for Cleared Ex-inmate

    The Ohio Court of Claims approves Howard's wrongful-imprisonment settlement.

  9. The Columbus Dispatch

    Freed Convict Gets $2.5 Million

    The state Controlling Board gives the settlement final approval.

  10. The Columbus Dispatch

    Prosecutor Agrees that Conviction Was Wrong

    Gary James is officially declared wrongfully convicted, clearing the way for his own claim.

Post-conviction

Randy Resh and Robert Gondor

Convicted in Portage County in 1990 for the 1988 death of Connie Nardi, the two friends won new trials after 12 years in prison.

In June 2002, visiting Judge Charles J. Bannon overturned the convictions, ruling that the juries never heard evidence that could have cleared the men. Prosecutors appealed. In January 2006, Jim argued Randy Resh's case before the Supreme Court of Ohio.

The court ordered new trials that December. Resh was found not guilty at his retrial, the charges against Gondor were dismissed, and both men were freed in 2007.

Justice was robbed.

James D. Owen, arguing for Randy Resh before the Supreme Court of Ohio

The coverage 2 articles

  1. Akron Beacon Journal

    They've Done 12 Years for Rape and Murder. Now, the Convictions Are Void. Was It a Setup?

    By Ed Meyer · Sunday front page

    Judge Bannon's ruling and the evidence the original juries never heard.

  2. Akron Beacon Journal

    High Court Hears Case of Convicts

    By Ed Meyer · Front page

    Jim's argument to the Supreme Court of Ohio on behalf of Randy Resh.

Jury trial

Jeremy Turner acquitted of murder

A Springfield self-defense case, retried after an appeals court found Turner's first lawyer had advised him inadequately.

Turner had pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter in 2003, but the Second District Court of Appeals later granted him a new trial. At the 2009 retrial, Jim argued that Turner fired in self-defense after men tried to rob him. The Clark County jury acquitted him of murder, convicting him only of having weapons under disability and attempted drug possession. With more than six years already served, he was released that day.

It vindicates a person's right to self-defense no matter who you are.

James D. Owen

The coverage 1 article

  1. Springfield News-Sun

    Jury Acquits Man of Murder

    By Valerie Lough

    The verdict, and the self-defense argument behind it.

Because each case is different, no expectations should be made about the results that can be achieved in your case or in any other case. Past performance is not an accurate predictor of future results.

Charged with a crime in Columbus? Talk to us before you talk to anyone else.

Free, confidential consultation · (614) 547-5757