Know Your Rights: How to Handle a Police Stop in Ohio
Being stopped by the police is one of the most common encounters people have with the criminal justice system — and one of the most mishandled. Most people either say too much, agree to things they have no obligation to agree to, or don’t realize their rights applied until it’s too late to invoke them. This guide walks through the key moments of a police stop from start to finish, so you know exactly what you are required to do and what you are not.
Do You Have to Pull Over — Even If You’ve Done Nothing Wrong?
Yes. When a police officer activates his lights and siren behind you, you must pull over — regardless of whether you have committed any traffic violation. There is no exception for “but I wasn’t doing anything wrong.”
Under Ohio law, failing to yield to an emergency vehicle is a misdemeanor. If you don’t pull over promptly, or if you speed up or make evasive movements, the officer may conclude you are fleeing. Fleeing a police officer in a vehicle is a first-degree misdemeanor. If your flight creates a substantial risk of serious physical harm to persons or property — which is nearly impossible to avoid in a moving car — it becomes a felony.
The practical rule: pull to the right at the first safe opportunity and stop. Do not slam on the brakes in the middle of a highway and do not accelerate. An unsafe stop is also a problem — it puts the officer on edge and could itself be a misdemeanor.
Whether or not the officer has any legal basis to stop you is a separate question entirely, and one your attorney can challenge in court. But the physical act of pulling over when lights appear behind you is not optional under any circumstances.
Showing Your License — and Knowing the Difference Between Orders and Requests
Once you’ve pulled over, the officer will approach and ask to see your driver’s license. This is one of the few things you are legally required to comply with. Ohio law requires a driver to display their license on demand to a peace officer.
How to do it: Turn off the engine. Roll down the window. Keep your hands visible. If you have to reach for your wallet, purse, or glovebox, tell the officer where the license is and that you’re going to reach for it before you move. Reaching toward your body or into a container without warning can alarm the officer. Say something like: “My license is in my back pocket — I’m going to reach for it now.”
Where to keep your license: Do not keep it in the same place you store private items. If you open a glovebox or pocket and the officer sees something he wasn’t supposed to see, he can use it. Once he sees it, it cannot be unseen. Keep your license somewhere that doesn’t require exposing anything else.
The most important thing to understand at a traffic stop: Police officers are trained to phrase their requests in the same polite tone regardless of whether you’re legally required to comply.
“May I see your license?” is not a question. It is a legal demand. You must comply.
“Would you please step out of the car?” is also a legal demand. You must comply (Pennsylvania v. Mimms).
“May I search your car?” is a real question. You may and should politely decline.
“Would you mind opening the trunk?” is a real question. You may and should politely decline.
The phrasing sounds identical. The legal weight is completely different. Knowing which is which is the difference between exercising your rights and accidentally waiving them.
Do You Have to Answer Police Questions?
You are never required to answer police questions beyond providing your name, address, and date of birth. This is true whether you are in a car, on a sidewalk, or in a police station.
This applies during a traffic stop too. After you’ve handed over your license, the officer may ask: “Where are you headed tonight?” “Have you been drinking?” “Where are you coming from?” None of these require an answer.
The rule: Do not lie, but do not volunteer information. Lying to a police officer can create new legal problems. But anything you voluntarily say — even something you think helps you — can be used against you. The Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination applies before an arrest, not just after.
The appropriate response when asked a question you don’t want to answer: “I’d prefer not to answer questions, sir. Am I required to?” In most cases, the officer will either move on or it will become clear he is trying to detain you further. Either way, you now have clarity on where things stand.
A specific scenario — “Where are you going in such a hurry?”
If you were speeding and the officer asks this, the WRONG answer is to apologize and explain. An apology looks like an admission of speeding, and your excuse almost certainly won’t matter. Ohio speeding laws have no “intent requirement” — you are guilty of speeding whether you meant to or not, and whether or not you have a good reason.
The also-wrong answer is to deny speeding or demand to see the radar gun. There is no legal requirement for the officer to show you his speed-measuring equipment at the scene. If you want to challenge the method of speed measurement, that’s what a courtroom is for.
The right approach: have your license and registration out and ready. Hand them over politely. Answer no questions about where you were going, why you were going fast, or whether you knew you were speeding.
Search Requests: The Right to Refuse — and Why You Should
When the officer asks to search your car, your body, or your belongings, the answer should always be no — even if you believe you have nothing to hide.
According to a Department of Justice report, more than 57% of people who were searched during a traffic stop consented to the search. Most of them didn’t realize they had the right to refuse. Consenting to a search waives your Fourth Amendment protection. If the officer finds anything — whether it belongs to you or not, whether you knew it was there or not — it will be admissible as evidence and you will have no legal basis to challenge the search later.
There are several reasons to refuse even if you think you’re clean: You may not know what is in your car. If anyone else has ever had access to your vehicle — a family member, a friend, a previous owner — there could be something in a door panel or under a seat that you never knew existed. You are also not an expert in what is and isn’t illegal. Things people don’t realize can be charged as crimes include sharing a prescription medication, having an amount of a substance that triggers trafficking thresholds, or carrying a legal item in an illegal way.
How to decline: “I don’t consent to any searches.” Say it plainly and without hostility. If the officer searches anyway, do not physically resist. Your remedy for an illegal search is in court — suppression of the evidence. If you consented, there is no remedy.
How Do You Know If You’re Under Arrest?
Most people think an arrest only happens when an officer puts handcuffs on them and says the words. That is not how the law works.
Under U.S. Supreme Court precedent, you are “seized” — legally equivalent to being under arrest — when a reasonable person in your position would not feel free to leave. You do not need handcuffs. You do not need to hear “you’re under arrest.” You just need circumstances where a reasonable person would conclude they cannot walk away.
Example: You were stopped for jaywalking. The officer wrote you a ticket and handed it to you — the stop is complete. But then he keeps your ID and says, “Walk with me to my car. I’ll give this back after you answer a few questions.” You are not free to leave because he has your ID and has told you he won’t return it until you cooperate. Even without handcuffs, you are under arrest.
If you are not certain whether you are being detained or free to leave, ask: “Am I free to go?” If the answer is no, or if the officer evades the question, assume you are in custody. The next words out of your mouth should be: “I want to speak to an attorney.”
What to Do When You’re Under Arrest
If you have been placed under arrest — whether formally, or effectively because you are not free to leave — there are two things to do and only two things:
1. Ask for an attorney. Say clearly: “I do not want to answer any questions. I want to speak to an attorney.” Do not just say “I’m invoking my right to remain silent.” If you invoke silence rather than requesting counsel, Ohio law allows police to wait a reasonable period and then resume questioning. If you specifically request an attorney, questioning must stop until you have had the opportunity to speak to one. The distinction is significant.
2. Say nothing else. Beyond your name, address, and date of birth, do not answer questions, do not offer explanations, and do not try to talk your way out of the situation.
Police officers in an interrogation situation are under no obligation to tell you the truth. Common tactics include telling a suspect the case against them is already airtight and this is just their chance to get their side on the record — when in reality the evidence is thin. Another common tactic is implying the officer has the ability to help the suspect’s situation if they cooperate. Police officers cannot offer plea deals. They cannot promise a lighter sentence. Judges decide sentencing in Ohio — not police.
Confessions and admissions obtained in interrogation often come from people who went in determined not to say anything and then gradually got pulled in. The only sure protection is to ask for an attorney immediately and then stop talking entirely.
Should You Take Roadside Sobriety Tests? Police Interaction, Part XVI
By Benjamin A. Tracy, Columbus Criminal Defense Lawyer and Civil Rights Attorney
This is the sixteenth part in a series of posts about what legal obligations you have when you interact with the police.
Situation 16
You and your friends have been to a bar. You’ve had two drinks but you feel you are sober enough to drive. Suddenly, however, flashing lights strobe behind you. You pull over and the officer comes to the window. He asks you to get out of the car and begins explaining the roadside sobriety tests he wants you to perform.
You might wonder what to do.
How To Respond
BEST answer: Let the police officer know you refuse to do any roadside tests of any kind until you have an opportunity to speak to an attorney about the matter.
GOOD answer: Tell the police officer you will not do any roadside tests.
MEDIOCRE answer: Tell the police officer you cannot do the roadside tests for health reasons or some other true excuse.
WRONG reaction: Do your best to pass the tests.
The BEST, GOOD, and even MEDIOCRE answers all recognize that you should not take a roadside test of any kind. In modern policing, there are essentially four types of sobriety tests that are administered at the side of the road – the portable breath test (PBT), the Walk and Turn, the One-legged Stand (OLS) and the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN).
The Three NHTSA-Approved Tests
Of the roughly 20 different balance and coordination tests officers sometimes use at the roadside, only three have been approved by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration:
Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN): The officer slowly moves a small object — a pen, flashlight, or finger — horizontally in front of your eyes while you keep your head still. The officer watches for involuntary bouncing or jerking of the eye as it tracks the object. If that movement (nystagmus) is observed before the object reaches a 45-degree angle from center, the officer treats it as a sign of impairment. The problem: the test is difficult to administer correctly, requires precise scoring, and the scientific literature identifies numerous medical conditions and physical factors completely unrelated to alcohol that can produce nystagmus. Its reliability is regularly challenged in court.
Walk and Turn: Walk nine steps heel-to-toe along a straight line, turn on one foot, and return nine steps the same way. Officers score this test on very specific clues — stepping off the line, using your arms for balance, taking the wrong number of steps, starting before told to. Many of these “failures” have nothing to do with intoxication.
One Leg Stand: Stand with one foot raised approximately six inches off the ground, counting out loud until instructed to stop. Officers look for swaying, hopping, putting the foot down, or raising your arms. Even mild wind, uneven pavement, or nervousness can affect this test.
Any other test an officer asks you to perform — walking a different pattern, reciting the alphabet, touching your nose — is not NHTSA-approved and carries even less scientific validity. The answer is the same regardless of which test is requested: refuse.
There are also a few other varieties which are not recognized in Ohio but sometimes are used. However, it does not matter what type of test it is or what is required to pass because the rule for dealing with this situation is simple – If you are asked to do a test and it is going to take place at the scene of the traffic stop, then you should refuse.
These Tests Don’t Measure Driving Ability
It’s worth understanding something fundamental about field sobriety tests: they do not test any skill Ohio actually requires to obtain a driver’s license.
When you got your Ohio license, you passed three things — a vision test, a written test, and a driving test. The BMV does not check for horizontal gaze nystagmus before deciding whether your vision qualifies you to drive. You did not walk heel-to-toe or stand on one leg during your driving test. And before the written test, you were given a study manual and told in advance exactly what you needed to score to pass.
Field sobriety tests offer none of that. There is no warm-up. There is no advance explanation of how you will be scored. Under roadside conditions — uneven pavement, headlights, nerves, cold weather — many perfectly sober and healthy people would struggle to pass them.
This is an argument experienced DUI defense attorneys regularly make to juries. These tests were not designed to determine whether someone is capable of driving safely. They were designed to generate documentation that justifies an arrest.
Don’t Be Fooled
A common thought in this situation is something like this, “Well, I’ve only had two beers. I can probably pass this test. And if I pass the test, the officer will let me go and that will be better than being arrested, having my car towed, hiring an attorney, and etc.” The problem with this common line of thought is it relies on a false assumption.
It assumes that the officer has not yet made up his mind as to whether or not you are drunk. The fact is, the officer pulled you over for a reason. He asked you to get out of the car for a reason. And now he is asking you to do the roadside tests for a reason. He already thinks you are drunk and he is almost certainly planning to arrest you no matter how you perform on the test.
In short, the WRONG reaction is wrong because when you take the test the officer is not really “testing” to see if you are drunk. He has already decided you are. What he is doing now is trying to collect evidence to give him an ironclad reason to arrest you and charge you with some species of driving while intoxicated (sometimes called DUI, DWI, OMVI, or OVI). Do not give it to him.
There is no penalty under Ohio law for refusing to take a roadside test (whether it is a portable breath test or any of the various physical tests). Since there is no penalty for refusing, since you are probably getting arrested regardless of how you perform on any “tests,” and since poor performance will only hurt your case, you should refuse.
How To Refuse A Roadside Sobriety Test
The final point worth noting here is it matters how you refuse the test.
If you refuse and offer an excuse (like an injury which prevents you from walking heel-to-toe) then you will be limited in what you can later say in court. That is, if you think of a better reason (which is also true) later for not having taken the test, you may be stuck with the excuse you provided at the scene of the stop.
Excuses
It is also hard to think of a true excuse that would prevent you from participating in any physical test and also would prevent you from taking a portable breath test or having your eyes examined (for the purposes of the HGN test). Moreover, if you provide an excuse that turns out not to be true, that will look bad later.
On the other hand, if you refuse and provide no excuse or explanation of any kind, you will be able to give thoughtful reasons later in court to explain your refusal. However, if you provide no reason at all, it will look like you are trying to hide the fact that you are drunk or, to use a legal term, “consciousness of guilt.”
For this reason, the BEST answer is that you do not want to do the tests until you consult with an attorney.
The officer is asking you to make a decision (whether or not to take the test) that impacts your legal rights. It is proper and reasonable to want legal advice before making that decision. Since the officer is not going to summon your attorney to the scene of the traffic stop, the end result is you will not have to take the test and you can explain your reluctance to take the test without looking guilty.
For more detailed information on DUIs (called OVIs in Ohio) please visit our dedicated DUI defense site and DUI blog.
Call (614) 547-5757 Free Consultation
If you are under investigation, or have been arrested by any law enforcement agency, feel free to call or contact one of our experienced Criminal Defense Attorneys, for a free initial consultation about your legal rights and possible defenses.