5354 North High Street, Columbus, OH 43214 · Free consultations Call (614) 547-5757
The Law Office ofJames D. Owen, LLC
Blog

What Is A Pat-Down Search?

Police Interaction

This is the fourth part in a series of posts about what legal obligation you have when you interact with the police and the first part of a three-part sub-series that will deal with pat-down searches.

The Situation

You were walking quickly along the street with your favorite black ski mask hanging out of your back pocket and an officer ordered you to stop. You did, and now he is attempting to question you about the armed robbery of a nearby convenience store. You tell him you respectfully refuse to answer his questions without your lawyer present. After a moment he asks you to turn around against a wall so that he may pat you down.

Do You Have to Comply with a Police Search

The BEST answer: Yes, but tell him that you do not consent to be searched.

The CORRECT answer: Yes.

The WRONG reaction: Push him away and say, “If I am not under arrest you can’t search me so get your hands off of me!”

The WRONG reaction is wrong for two reasons. First, we know from prior blog posts that you are not entitled to “self-help” when dealing with the police. That is, if you think they are doing something illegal, you cannot physically stop them at that moment. Your only recourse is to go to court later and complain about it.

So you cannot and should not ever try to physically stop an officer from searching you or patting you down. Second, the Supreme Court decided in the Sixties that an officer who has “reasonable articulable suspicion” can conduct a Terry stop.

The Terry stop is a period of detention that is not quite a full arrest and is named after the case, Terry v. Ohio. In other words, if, a police officer makes observations that in his experience, lead him to believe you are either going to commit a crime or have committed a crime, he can stop you for a brief period to conduct an investigation.

If he has reason to believe that you may be armed and present a danger to him, he may conduct a limited “pat-down” for his safety. In this case, the officer stopped you because he believes you were connected to the armed robbery. Thus, since it was an “armed” robbery, he has reason to believe you are armed and dangerous. For this reason, he has a right to pat you down for his safety.

Submit to the Pat Down

The CORRECT answer is yes, you must submit to the pat-down. However, the BEST answer includes letting the officer know that you are not consenting to the search. The Terry stop and the “pat-down” are limited searches and seizures.

The Terry stop has to be short in duration and should not include transporting you to a different location or physically restraining you by handcuffs or similar devices. The “pat-down” should consist of the officer running his hands over the outside of your clothing to feel for objects which may be weapons or objects of obvious criminality.

If the officer feels such an object, he may remove it and examine it, but otherwise, the “pat-down” is limited to literally, a “pat-down.” Thus, within the scope of the “pat-down,” the officer may not open your purse, briefcase, backpack or other containers.

However, if you give consent for him to search, he can search anywhere you give consent for. If, for example, you tell him that he can go search your house, he can. He does not need a warrant or a reason – all he needs is your consent. Thus, it is best to make clear that you will cooperate with him to the extent that you are required to by law, but that you do not consent to any searches.

What If the Officer Doesn’t Have the Right to Pat You Down?

Not every pat-down is legal. The U.S. Supreme Court made clear in Arizona v. Johnson that an officer who stops someone for a crime is not automatically entitled to pat them down. The officer must also have a separate, articulable reason to believe you are armed and dangerous.

If, for example, you were stopped for a minor non-violent offense — trespassing, a noise violation, jaywalking — the officer may not have the legal basis to conduct a pat-down. Being stopped for that kind of offense doesn’t automatically create a reason to suspect you’re carrying a weapon.

In Ohio, a person only commits the crime of obstructing official business by taking an “affirmative act” of obstruction — physically running away, for instance. Simply standing still and passively refusing to spread your legs or raise your hands does not, on its own, constitute a crime.

That said, actually refusing to cooperate physically is dangerous even when the pat-down is illegal. If the officer genuinely (even incorrectly) believes you are armed, refusing to comply can escalate the encounter in ways that put you at serious risk. The right answer is to comply physically, but to calmly and clearly tell the officer you do not consent to the search and do not believe he has the right to conduct it. You cannot stop an illegal search at the scene — but your stated objection protects your ability to challenge it in court.

What Can an Officer Do During a Pat-Down — and What Can’t He Do?

A pat-down is a frisk, and a frisk is limited to a search for weapons. The officer runs his hands over the outside of your clothing, feeling for objects that might be weapons. That is the extent of what he is legally permitted to do.

Here is a critical point that most people don’t know: if the officer feels something during the pat-down that is clearly not a weapon — a soft plastic bag, for example — he generally cannot reach into your pocket to remove it. The pat-down gave him no authority to retrieve non-weapon items.

What the officer will typically do in that situation is ask you what the object is, or ask permission to look inside your pocket. Do not answer, and do not give consent. If you admit what the object is or give the officer permission to search, he will have all the legal justification he needs to retrieve it, and challenging the search in court later becomes nearly impossible.

Without your admission or consent, the officer faces a harder choice. He can end the pat-down and let you go. Or he can try to justify reaching into your pocket by claiming: (1) he smelled the odor of drugs through your clothing, or (2) through the “plain feel” doctrine — that when his hand touched the object, he immediately knew from the feel alone that it was contraband. Both of these justifications can be challenged in court. Your admission cannot.

The correct answer if an officer asks you what is in your pocket: say nothing.

Pat-Downs During a Traffic Stop

The rules are the same during a traffic stop, but there is one additional wrinkle worth knowing about.

The U.S. Supreme Court decided in Pennsylvania v. Mimms that an officer may order you out of your vehicle during a traffic stop. You do not have a choice about getting out. The reason for the stop doesn’t matter, and the weather doesn’t matter — when the officer says “please step out of the car,” that is an order, not a request.

However, being ordered out of the car is not the same as consenting to a search. An officer may only conduct a pat-down if he has a reason to believe you are armed and dangerous. A routine traffic stop for speeding, a lane violation, or a broken taillight does not create that justification. Speeding is not a violent offense. Without additional specific facts suggesting you may be armed, the pat-down would exceed the officer’s legal authority.

As with any illegal pat-down: you cannot physically resist. Your only remedy is to make clear at the scene that you do not consent, and then challenge the search in court. An experienced criminal defense attorney can often get evidence obtained from an improper traffic stop pat-down suppressed.

If you are under investigation, or have been arrested by any Columbus law enforcement agency, feel free to contact one of our experienced Columbus Criminal Defense Attorneys, for a free initial consultation about your legal rights and possible defenses.

Keep reading

Related articles

Charged with a crime in Columbus? Talk to us before you talk to anyone else.

Free, confidential consultation · (614) 547-5757