5354 North High Street, Columbus, OH 43214 · Free consultations Call (614) 547-5757
The Law Office ofJames D. Owen, LLC
Blog

What Is Hearsay?

Criminal Defense Topics

Most people think, and they are right, that hearsay is not allowed in court. Most people also have an idea about what hearsay is. These ideas are usually wrong. Generally, people seem to believe that if June tells Steve something, Steve cannot repeat it in court because that would be hearsay. This idea even has a kind of linguistic plausibility. He hears her, then he says it – Hearsay.

However, this is not, legally speaking, what hearsay is. A statement is hearsay if it is a statement that is “not ma[d]e while testifying at the current trial or hearing” and is “offer[ed] in evidence to prove the truth of the matter asserted in the statement.” That definition is hard to grasp and some explanation is in order.

Out of Court Statements

The first bit, about a statement “not made while testifying at the current trial or hearing,” sometimes called an “out of court statement,” means anything that someone said, communicated, or even wrote, outside the current court proceeding.

And, “offered in evidence to prove the truth of the matter asserted” means that the person who is attempting to repeat the statement wants to repeat it to show that what was said was true. An example illustrates this well.

Suppose June tells Steve that George was arrested and Steve tries to testify about what June told him.

If Steve says what June told him to show that George actually was arrested, then it is hearsay and cannot be allowed into evidence. If, on the other hand, Steve says what June told him to explain why he got upset when he was on the phone with June, then it is not hearsay.

That is, Steve is saying that June told him that George was arrested not in order to show that George was, in fact, arrested, but instead to show that Steve was very upset when he heard that George had been arrested.

The reason this example is not hearsay is because it actually does not matter whether George was really arrested – June could be wrong or lying. The important part is that Steve heard from June that George was arrested and because he heard that (and rightly or wrongly believed it), he became upset.

Why is What is Known, Known?

The common sense justification for this somewhat puzzling legal distinction is the answer to this question: Why do the people in the example know what they know? Steve cannot testify that June said George was arrested in order to establish that George was arrested because Steve does not personally know that George was arrested. He was not there to see it.

In addition, if Steve were to be cross examined, he could not provide the jury with much guidance as to whether or not George really was arrested because he does not know how June knows that George was arrested. In contrast, Steve definitely does know, probably better than anyone, that he heard June say that George was arrested and that hearing that made him upset. If he were to be cross-examined about that, he could explain when he heard June say it, what exactly she said, in what context she said it, and why it made him upset.

Common Exceptions to the Hearsay Rule

As mentioned, Ohio recognizes roughly thirty exceptions to the hearsay rule. Two of the most important are the ones most likely to come up in a criminal case:

Prior Inconsistent and Consistent Statements

When a witness is on the stand and being cross-examined, the attorney cross-examining that witness can use the witness’s own prior statements — made outside of the current proceeding — as evidence, provided those statements are inconsistent with what the witness is now saying in court. This allows prior testimony, written statements, or recorded statements to be used to challenge the witness’s credibility.

This rule also works in the other direction: prior consistent statements can be introduced to support a witness’s credibility if one side is attempting to portray the witness as a liar.

Party Admissions

Perhaps the most commonly encountered hearsay exception in criminal cases is the rule on party admissions. Any statement made by a party to the lawsuit — or that party’s authorized representative — can be used against that party, and this use is not subject to the hearsay rule.

In practice, this is why police officers are permitted to repeat in court what a defendant told them at the time of arrest or during questioning. The defendant is a party to the criminal case, so anything they said — whether to police, in a recorded phone call, in a text message, or anywhere else — can be introduced against them. As a party in a lawsuit, anything you have ever said can and will be used against you as far as the hearsay rules are concerned.

This is one of the core reasons experienced criminal defense attorneys advise clients not to speak to police without counsel present.

If you are under investigation, or have been arrested by any law enforcement agency, feel free to contact one of our experienced Criminal Defense Attorneys, for a free initial consultation about your legal rights and possible defenses. In addition, if you have been wrongfully convicted, arrested, imprisoned, maliciously prosecuted, or have suffered some other wrong, feel free to contact one of our experienced attorneys, for a free initial consultation.

Keep reading

Related articles

Charged with a crime in Columbus? Talk to us before you talk to anyone else.

Free, confidential consultation · (614) 547-5757