Can the best criminal defense lawyer win every criminal case?

It depends on who you ask. Even the best criminal defense attorneys have different views. Gerry Spence, one of the best trial lawyers in America, says “yes.”  Others say to forget about ever winning against the government.

Why Top Rated Lawyers Give Opposing Views

Gerry Spence, one of America’s greatest trial lawyers, says that with creativity, effort, and a little luck any criminal case can be won.

A prominent Columbus criminal defense attorney takes the exact opposite view. This lawyer, ranked number 1 by Google for “Columbus criminal defense,” says in a YouTube video: “This [the criminal justice system] isn’t about … walking scot-free. No judges are going to let that happen. No prosecutors are going to let that happen.”

How can the great Gerry Spence, and one of Ohio’s premiere criminal defense attorneys take diametrically opposed views. It’s based on their experience.

Gerry Spence has never lost a criminal case, he is the best criminal defense lawyer in Ohio.   Most recently, in a politically charged federal case brought by the U.S. Department of Justice, Spence won a complete acquittal for famous trial lawyer Geoffrey Fieger, who was charged in a 10-count indictment with federal campaign contribution violations, conspiracy, and obstruction of justice.

Spence has won many other nationally known criminal cases, including the defense of Randy Weaver at Ruby Ridge, the defense of Imelda Marcos, the wife of the former Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos, and the murder defenses of Sandy Jones and Ed Cantrell. Based on his experience, Gerry Spence believes that any criminal case can be won.

On the other hand, the top ranked Columbus defense lawyer, to our knowledge has never won a complete acquittal in a felony jury trial. Based on his experience, serious criminal cases aren’t won.

The real truth is somewhere in between. Many, if not most, serious criminal cases can be won. The only way for your lawyer to find out is to thoroughly investigate the case. The best criminal defense lawyers are fearless investigators.  Are key witnesses still available? If they are, are they credible? Can they be impeached based on motive, ability to observe, or prior inconsistent statements? Was evidence constitutionally obtained?  Lawyers without a proven history winning jury trials are not in a good position to answer those questions.

Why a Winning Record Matters

If you want to know whether you can win your criminal case, hire a lawyer with a proven record winning serious criminal cases. Only he or she can give you an objective answer.  This also gives you an additional advantage.  Hiring a lawyer with a proven record lets the prosecutor know you will be ready to go to trial. It gives you an edge to negotiate a favorable plea before trial if that’s the route to take. And if your case does go to trial, your lawyer will be better able to reach the promised land — a NOT GUILTY verdict.

Good criminal defense lawyers are proud of their record. They will give you a list of important cases tried and won. Mediocre lawyers won’t.

Although prior wins cannot predict future results, lawyers with an established record are better positioned to favorably resolve your case, whether through plea or trial.

A NOT GUILTY verdict – the Only Real Award a Criminal Defense Lawyer can Earn

Some lawyers try to substitute YouTube videos, fancy certificates, or “Top Attorney” plaques, for a failed record of courtroom success. Don’t be fooled. A NOT GUILTY verdict is the only real award a criminal defense attorney can earn.