A fatal traffic accident can lead to criminal charges even when there was no intent to hurt anyone. Ohio law recognizes four separate vehicular homicide charges, and which one applies — and how severely it’s punished — depends heavily on impairment, driving conduct, and fault.
The Four Types of Vehicular Homicide Charges in Ohio
Ohio law recognizes four distinct ways a person can be criminally charged for causing another person’s death while operating a vehicle: Aggravated Vehicular Homicide (Drug or Alcohol Related), Aggravated Vehicular Homicide (Reckless Driving), Vehicular Homicide, and Vehicular Manslaughter.
Aggravated Vehicular Homicide — Drug or Alcohol Related
This is the most serious of the four charges, applying when impairment by drugs or alcohol contributed to a fatal accident. It can be charged as a felony of the first, second, or third degree depending on the circumstances and the driver’s history, and it typically draws the most aggressive prosecution of the four vehicular homicide offenses because it combines a death with an underlying OVI violation. A prior OVI conviction, a suspended license, or an especially high blood alcohol reading can each push a case toward the higher end of the felony range.
Aggravated Vehicular Homicide — Reckless Driving
This charge applies when a death results from reckless operation of a vehicle, without impairment necessarily being a factor. “Reckless” in this context carries the same meaning described on our Reckless Homicide page — the driver must have consciously disregarded a known, substantial risk, such as by driving at extreme speed, running red lights, or weaving aggressively through traffic, rather than simply making a driving mistake.
Vehicular Homicide
This charge applies to a death caused by ordinary negligent operation of a vehicle, generally involving a lower degree of fault than the aggravated versions above. It often applies to fatal accidents involving distracted driving, a failure to yield, or another lapse in attention that a reasonable driver should have avoided, but which falls short of reckless conduct.
Vehicular Manslaughter
This is the least serious of the four, typically involving a death that resulted from a minor traffic violation — such as a rolling stop or a minor lane violation — and it is punishable only as a misdemeanor. Even though it’s the lowest-level charge in this group, a conviction still creates a permanent criminal record and can affect a person’s driving privileges.
Penalties for Vehicular Homicide Charges in Ohio
These four offenses range dramatically in severity — from Vehicular Manslaughter, a second-degree misdemeanor punishable by a maximum of 90 days in jail, to Aggravated Vehicular Homicide involving drugs or alcohol, which can be charged as a first-degree felony punishable by up to 11 years in prison.
How Vehicular Homicide Differs from Other Ohio Homicide Charges
Vehicular homicide charges are prosecuted under statutes tied specifically to traffic and OVI law, rather than the general homicide statutes that apply to Murder, Manslaughter, and Reckless or Negligent Homicide. Because of this, they often involve different evidence — accident reconstruction, blood alcohol testing, and vehicle data — and different defense strategies than a typical homicide case.
Common Defenses in Vehicular Homicide Cases
Effective defenses in these cases often focus on disputing the state’s account of how the accident actually happened, challenging blood alcohol or drug testing procedures, or arguing that the death was a true accident rather than the result of criminal recklessness or negligence.
See all 12 ways we defend murder and homicide cases in Ohio.
Successful Case Results on Vehicular Homicide
James D. Owen successfully defended a client, identified as Timothy C., in an Aggravated Vehicular Homicide case by disputing the state’s theory of the cause of death — the same cause-of-death defense strategy has also been used successfully in Aggravated Murder cases.
See some of our homicide case victories.
Because each case is different, no expectations should be made about the results that can be achieved in your case or in any other case. Past performance is not an accurate predictor of future results.
Related: OVI/DUI and Other Vehicular Crimes in Ohio
This page focuses specifically on the four charges that apply when someone dies as a result of a vehicle-related incident. For information on OVI/DUI charges and other vehicle-related offenses that do not involve a death, see our dedicated Vehicular Crimes page.
Learn more about OVI, DUI, and other vehicular crimes in Ohio.