5354 North High Street, Columbus, OH 43214 · Free consultations Call (614) 547-5757
The Law Office ofJames D. Owen, LLC
Handgun, spent shell casings and a yellow evidence marker beside crime scene tape
Ohio Homicide Defense Attorney

12 Ways to Defend a Murder Case in Ohio

A murder or homicide charge is not automatically a conviction. Over more than four decades defending Ohio’s most serious criminal cases, James D. Owen has developed and refined twelve distinct defense strategies — often combining two or three of them in a single case to build the strongest possible defense.

The 12 Defenses We Use to Win Murder and Homicide Cases

1. Self-Defense or Defense of Another

This defense applies when the accused did cause the death, but was legally justified because they reasonably feared death or serious bodily harm to themselves or someone else. Jeremy Turner was acquitted of Serious Felony Murder and two counts of Involuntary Manslaughter using exactly this defense. Because self-defense involves its own detailed body of Ohio law, it’s covered in full on its own page.

Read our about self-defense in Ohio homicide cases.

2. Alibi Defense or Mistaken Identification

An alibi defense means that the accused was at a place other than where the crime occurred at the time the crime occurred. Under Ohio criminal rule 12.1 the accused in a criminal case who opposed to offer testimony to establish and alibi, must not less than 30 days before trial, in a felony case must file a notice in writing that includes specific information as to the place at which the accused claims to have been at the time of the alleged offense.

False identification is one of the leading causes of wrongful convictions, especially in the chaotic, high-stress aftermath of a homicide. Unduly suggestive police lineups, inaccurate photo identifications, and simple eyewitness error can all lead to the wrong person being charged. This defense has been used successfully in Ohio cases even where the state was seeking the death penalty.

3. The Death Was an Accident

This defense applies when the accused did not purposely cause the death, but rather caused it by accident — meaning an unintentional event without any design or purpose to bring it about. This strategy has led to successful outcomes in two Aggravated Vehicular Homicide cases and one Aggravated Murder case.

4. The State’s Science Doesn’t Hold Up

Forensic evidence is not infallible, and prosecutors sometimes rely on scientific conclusions that don’t hold up to independent scrutiny. In a Portage County, Ohio case, prosecutors believed a truck bedliner contained a murder victim’s blood in the exact location a confidential informant claimed the body had been transported. Independent testing by a retained expert proved the substance was actually human sweat, with DNA too degraded to connect to any specific person.

5. Present But Not Involved (the “Bystander” Defense)

This defense applies when the accused was present at the scene, but someone else present actually caused the death. It was used successfully in the Franklin County, Ohio death penalty murder case of William Berry II, who was found not guilty of all charges after the credibility of the state’s key eyewitness was thoroughly challenged.

6. No Purpose or Knowledge to Cause Death

Similar to the accident defense, this strategy applies in situations where the accused’s actions did cause a death, but without any purpose or knowledge that a death would result — undermining the specific mental state most homicide charges require.

7. A Flawed Police Investigation

A rushed or incomplete police investigation can lead directly to a wrongful charge or conviction. This approach was used to help exonerate Timothy Howard, Gary James, Randy Resh, and Robert Gondor — four men wrongfully convicted of homicides they did not commit.

Read the full story of these exonerations.

8. It Was a Lesser Offense, Not Murder

Sometimes the evidence supports a homicide occurred, just not the one charged. A client identified as Jacob M. was charged with Aggravated Murder and Murder for the shooting death of his wife, but was ultimately convicted only of the lesser offense of Reckless Homicide after the defense argued the shooting was accidental or, at worst, reckless.

9. The Cause, Manner, or Time of Death Is Disputed

This defense challenges the prosecution’s account of how, when, or why a death occurred. It was used successfully in the Aggravated Vehicular Homicide case of Timothy C., and has also been used in a Serious Felony Murder case involving disputed shaken-baby evidence, where retained medical experts concluded the evidence did not support the state’s theory.

10. A False or Coerced Confession

Confessions are not always reliable, particularly when obtained through prolonged or improper interrogation tactics. This defense has been used successfully to obtain a dismissal in an alleged gross sexual imposition case, using experts among the foremost in the country on false confessions.

11. Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity

This defense applies when the accused lacked the mental capacity to understand that their conduct was wrong. It is a difficult defense to win and is used selectively, based on the specific facts and available expert evaluation.

12. Character and Reputation Evidence

Ohio Evidence Rule 404(A)(1) allows an accused to offer evidence of a pertinent character trait, such as a reputation for peacefulness or honesty. This strategy was used successfully in a Franklin County case for a client accused of assaulting a neighbor with a set of brass knuckles; after coworkers testified to the client’s reputation for truthfulness and peacefulness, the jury returned a unanimous not-guilty verdict after a short deliberation.

How These Defenses Work Together in a Real Case

Most winning homicide cases don’t rely on a single defense in isolation — they combine two or three of these strategies to build a complete, believable account of what actually happened. A case built only on “the science doesn’t hold up,” for example, is often strengthened significantly when paired with a mistaken identification argument or a challenge to the police investigation itself.

Because each case is different, no expectations should be made about the results that can be achieved in your case or in any other case. Past performance is not an accurate predictor of future results.

Case Results

Results in cases like this

  • State of Ohiov.Turner

    Not guilty
    Murder · Jury verdict

    Our client, a young central Ohio man, was charged with Murder and three counts of Involuntary Manslaughter. The jury found the client NOT GUILTY on all four charges. He was immediately released from jail.

  • State of Ohiov.Hairston

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict · Capital case

    Indictment for Aggravated Murder with death specifications among other charges. After a 3-week jury trial, the Columbus jury announced a verdict of NOT GUILTY on all charges.

  • State of Ohiov.Walker

    Not guilty
    Jury verdict

    The client, a young Columbus man, was charged with Aggravated Vehicular Homicide. The jury announced a NOT GUILTY verdict on all charges.

Because each case is different, no expectations should be made about the results that can be achieved in your case or in any other case. Past performance is not an accurate predictor of future results.

Frequently Asked Questions about Defending Murder Cases in Ohio

What are the most common defenses to a murder charge in Ohio?

The most common defenses include self-defense, mistaken identification, accident, disputing the state’s scientific evidence, arguing the accused was present but not involved, and arguing the facts support a lesser offense like manslaughter.

Can I claim self-defense if I already admitted I caused the death?

Yes. Self-defense doesn’t require denying you caused the death — it requires showing you were legally justified in using force because you reasonably feared death or serious bodily harm.

What if the police think they identified the wrong person?

Mistaken identification is one of the leading causes of wrongful convictions, especially in the high-stress aftermath of a homicide. An experienced defense attorney can challenge suggestive lineups, unreliable eyewitness testimony, and flawed identification procedures.

Can a murder charge be reduced by challenging the science?

Yes. Forensic evidence like DNA, blood spatter, or cause-of-death conclusions isn’t infallible. Independent expert testimony has been used to show the state’s science was wrong or unsupported in actual Ohio murder cases.

How does a “bystander” or “present but not involved” defense work?

This defense argues that while the accused was at the scene, another person actually committed the killing. It requires a careful factual investigation to show who was truly responsible.

What is the insanity defense and how often does it work?

A defendant found not guilty by reason of insanity is found to have lacked the mental capacity to understand their conduct was wrong. It’s a difficult defense to win and is used selectively, based on the specific facts and available expert evaluation.

Can good character testimony really change a jury’s verdict?

Yes, in the right case. Testimony from people who know the accused well about their reputation for honesty or peacefulness can meaningfully influence a jury, though it also opens the door for the prosecution to challenge that character.

In the News

Recognized by regional and national media

Read the press coverage
Super LawyersThe Columbus DispatchCleveland Plain DealerAkron Beacon JournalCincinnati EnquirerSpringfield News-SunPittsburgh Post-Gazette

Charged with a crime in Columbus? Talk to us before you talk to anyone else.

Free, confidential consultation · (614) 547-5757